Posted 26 October 2011 - 01:33 AM
Last month I purchased a Caviar Black 1.5TB internal SATA hard drive. I did a clean install of Windows XP Pro on it. At the time, I opted to split the drive into three partitions (C: 104GB, D: 976GB, E: 420GB). According to Disk Management, C: is the primary partition, and D: and E: are extended partitions and logical drives. Windows has been upgraded to Service Pack 3.
I have run into a recurring problem with the D: partition. Basically, whenever I try to modify a file on that drive the program I am using stops responding. Then, any program afterwards that I try to start won't. When I click on the Start menu and "Turn Off Computer", nothing happens (the dialog box asking if I want to restart or shut down doesn't appear). Ctrl-Alt-Delete doesn't bring up the Task Manager. Basically, everything stops responding, except I can still move the cursor. The only way to turn off the computer is to press and hold the power switch. Once restarted, everything works fine, until I try to modify a file on the D: drive. I have had no problems with the C: or E: partitions.
I don't know what causes the problem in the first place. What I do know is that when the D: drive starts having this problem, any of the below actions will cause the symptoms described in the previous paragraph.
Downloading a file with Firefox and trying to save it to the D: drive.
Opening a file on the D: drive with Open Office, making changes, and clicking save.
Creating a *.txt file on the C: drive, opening it with notepad and trying to save it to the D: drive.
Trying to delete a file on the D: drive to the recycle bin.
Interestingly, I am still able to copy files to the D: drive without a problem.
I can copy everything on the D: drive to the E: drive with no problem.
If I start Windows in Safe Mode, then I can modify and delete files on the D: drive with no problem.
I've scanned the computer with Avast and the free version of Malwarebytes' Anti-Malware. I also scanned it with Windows Defender and Spybot. None of the scans showed any problems. I've also run Check Disk on the D: drive with the "scan for and attempt recovery of bad sectors" box checked. No problems were reported.
In an attempt to fix the problem I have used Disk Management to delete and recreate the D: partition. I've done so multiple times. One time, I even recreated it as two partitions, D: and Z:. Both partitions experienced the problem.
I've recreated it using a different letter (I believe I used J:). The problem still occured.
I've tried renaming it to a different letter (without deleting and recreating). Didn't work.
Usually, after I had deleted and recreated the partition, it would work fine for awhile.
Sometimes the problem would resurface right after I had copied its files back onto the drive.
Other times the problem would resurface after installing a program.
Here is the sequence of events prior to the most recent occurrence of the problem. I had saved a file on the D: drive on Monday, the 25th. I put my computer into Stand By. While I was at work today (Tuesday), the power was shut off. So instead of resuming from stand by, the computer had to boot up. Once I logged in, Adobe Flash asked to upgrade and I let it. I then opened the same file on the D: drive in Open Office, updated it and clicked save - the program stopped responding. After restarting my computer, I tried to delete a different file (a text file) on the D: drive and the problem occurred.
I searched on the web, but it didn't appear anyone else has had this problem. It's the first time I've ever encountered it. Since the problem completely disappears in Safe Mode, I'm inclined to think it's software related.
Let me know if you have any thoughts of what I could try or look for. Let me know if I missed any important information.