I bought an external Seagate 750 GB Free Agent drive. It works fine in USB mode, but my computer does not see it when I try to connect with the Esata cable. I have an Asus P5K MB and running XP. Any suggestions?

Well...does an eSATA connection call for a driver?

If so, was said driver installed?

Check Device Manager for clues?

You mean that this drive appears properly in My Computer/Explorer when connected by USB?

Is the drive formatted?

Louis

Ensure the eSATA port is enabled in the BIOS setup. If XP doesn't have SATA drivers installed (ie the system's internal HDD and optical drive are IDE), the motherboard SATA drivers will need to be installed, or the port will have to be set to emulate IDE if such an option is available in the BIOS. It may not be, as IDE has no hotswap capability, which rather defeats the purpose of eSATA.

There's also a slight possibility that the eSATA connection on the enclosure simply doesn't work.

My internal hard drives are both SATA. The drive is formatted and reads fine in USB. But I just discovered it will read it if I plug it in at bootup. I guess it is not a hot-swappable

eSATA should be hot-swappable.

If you haven't already, double check that the SATA drives aren't being operated in IDE emulation mode. XP could still have been installed without SATA drivers by this means.

Or even if the internal drives are being operated in AHCI mode and hence XP is using SATA drivers, if the eSATA channel has individual mode settings and is in IDE mode, Windows then uses its IDE drivers to access the eSATA drive. That will give the exact symptom you describe - if the drive is connected at boot-up, the IDE driver finds it, but IDE has no hot-swap capability, so cannot install a drive that is connected subsequent to boot time.

Sorry.. can you repeat that in english lol

I'll try, if you promise to read in English

I scanned through the user manual for your board, and it's most likely that the eSATA port is just set to IDE mode.

The eSATA port is provided by the motherboard's second SATA controller, a J-Micron which has 3 selectable modes; RAID, IDE or AHCI (which means SATA). The manual says "The J-Micron controller item in the BIOS is set to [IDE] by default."

That means the eSATA port will make the eSATA drive appear to be an IDE drive, and Windows will use its own IDE driver for it, and not need a SATA driver. But it only works like an IDE drive, no hot-swap.

If you want to, you can download the manual and SATA driver from here:

http://support.asus.com/download/download....s&model=P5K

or the driver CD that came with the board or computer system would also have them on it.

The drivers for the J-Micron controller are in the section called RAID (because the controller can do RAID). If the XP driver was installed onto your computer, you could then go into the BIOS setup screen, and change the J-Micron controller mode to [AHCI] instead of [IDE].

Windows would then see the drive if it is plugged in after boot-up, and there would be a safe eject icon on the taskbar so the drive could be safely unplugged again without shutting the computer down.

I downloaded and installed the JMicron. I went into bios and the only option i saw under sata was IDE. Also when i open the Jmicron in windows.. it says J micron is not available in sata or ide but only in raid. Did i do something wrong?

The J-Micron setting is not under the SATA section in the BIOS, that is for the internal SATA drives. The J-Micron has its own options in the Onboard Devices section of the Advanced menu. There's one option to Enable/Disable the J-Micron controller, the next option below that is Controller Mode [IDE, AHCI, RAID]. Select AHCI there.

I made the switch but it still doesn't read the drive in esata mode

Hmm, a Google search suggests you're not the only one with this sort of problem.

For example, it's long but this topic on the Seagate forums makes interesting reading:

http://forums.seagate.com/stx/board/messag...ding&page=1

It looks my choices are to either use it at bootup, or else connect through USB. What a pain as I wanted faster write times. I use the drive to make a new weekly image file of my primary HD with Acronis True Image (the best disaster protection!) and also to store backups of movies, music etc.I should add that I did not buy the external drive. I purchased a Seagate Barracuda 750 GB internal SATA 300 and then bought an external Esata case for it.

If it's purely for backups and you're not really needing to move it around between systems, then not having the hotswap capability may not be much of a problem. Only my desktop system has eSATA, so I use my Vantec enclosure on USB with my laptops, & that works out OK.

That's what I will do. It's just annoying to buy a product and not have it function properly...

Some of us...return things which we can prove are defective.

That's what warranties, RMAs, etc. are all about.

Louis

And some of us are not smug and sarcastic.

That's what human decency is all about.